Thanks Ed - I don't think it is related to that but I will look into it. Below are the actual indexer parameters being used - I do not see any exit or INDEXSTYLE=AFP reference.
cc = yes
cctype = a
convert = yes
cpgid = 500
field1 = 0,18,7
field2 = 0,25,5
field3 = 0,30,17
field4 = 0,47,40
field5 = 0,87,8
field6 = 0,87,8
fileformat = record
imageout = asis
index1 = X'E2E3A89785',field1
index2 = X'C2819592D596',field2
index3 = X'C18383A3D596',field3
index4 = X'C3A4A2A3D5819485',field4
index5 = X'E2C481A385',field5
index6 = X'E2D78599899684',field6
indexstartby = 99
formdef=F1CSFCRE
reslib = /arscfg/resources:/arscfg/fonts
restype = fdef,pseg,ovly
trigger1 = *,1,X'5A008AD3EEEE000000'
INDEXOBJ=ALL