Since you're out of support, I suggest you just do a new application group with a field named something like- report name
Then do-
database value 1, <AG Description..I usually do like - PDF>
database value 2, <AG Description..I usually do like - XLS>
Then, APP1-PDF mapped to AG, and APP1-XLS mapped to AG. That's how I've always done it.
Might be a pain on the folks who are sending, but the only other option would be to probably extend your support contract with IBM for 10.1, or upgrade to 10.5
Or, a single app group for each app
Or, extend your support contract for 10.1
Or, goto 10.5